Best Picture Reviews: All Quiet on the Western Front (1930)

All Quiet on the Western Front, 1930
All Quiet on the Western Front, 1930

What a difference one year makes.  In 1929 it was the pitiful Broadway Melody, a weak musical that somehow stood out in the year movies transitioned away from silent films.  Just a year later, along came All Quiet on the Western Front, a timeless, powerful movie based on the German army in World War I.

The movie centers around a group of German teenagers who are all quickly talked into joining the war effort.  They’re all super excited after a rousing speech from a professor of some sort, and after minimal training are sent out to war almost immediately.  As one might expect, it does not go well for our group of youngsters.  Those who actually lived were scarred for life.

I’m not much of a history buff, and embarassingly had to ask Lauren before the movie for a little background on World War I, but it wasn’t really relevant in this movie.  It is said that this movie remains relevant even today, as things haven’t changed much regarding looking death in the face by going to war.

When we started watching this movie, it was already 11pm.  Believe it or not, Lauren was the one who fell fast asleep.  I started to doze off a time or two, but there was so much noise from bombs and machine guns going off that I popped back up within a second or two.  A couple of the characters basically went crazy spending their days burrowed away in the trenches and lost their minds.  One guy can’t take it anymore and goes running away screaming in a very high womanly pitch and predictably gets shot down.

By movie’s end, one of the guys returns from war and is asked to speak in front of a class of boys, just as the movie began.  Only this time, he tells the boys the real truth about how nothing good comes of joining the war effort.  Unlike the boys earlier in the film, these young chaps aren’t very excited and don’t go running out to sign up for war.  This guy who had returned home is so psychologically scarred that he can no longer live a normal life and goes back to join his pals in the fight.  The movie ends with a scene of thousands of crosses over the fields of all the fallen soldiers.

So, to sum it up, it was a very intense movie that remains historically significant.  Many recognize it as the first real war movie and today’s directors acknowledge it as the inspiration behind their films, including Steven Spielberg with Saving Private Ryan.

It wasn’t an enjoyable movie to watch, but I don’t think it is supposed to be.  I don’t think anyone’s gonna see this and want to watch it again and again.  But it was a great movie for other reasons.  “Haunting” is the best word I can think of to describe All Quiet.  Compared side by side with 1929’s Broadway Melody, these two films aren’t even in the same class.  All Quiet wins in a landslide.

Next in the queue, 1931’s Cimmaron.


  1. Dear Mr. Glanzer – this has nothing to do with “All Quiet”. I am here on a totally different quest, maybe right up your alley. Jesse Cooney, yes the beloved character Jesse James Cooney. Be very careful with this assighnment; as he could become very pissed off. I am, as I stated TJ and used to date Jesse’s dad and had a child with him (Dad). This child is most interested in meeting or having one conversation with his 1/2 brother. Jesse’s sister, has spent the night and is always calling to listen to the tall tails of the gifted Cooney gene. My mission, if you choose to accept it is this; Please tell Jesse to quit being a stubborn jackass and make at least one attempt in listening to his 1/2 brother. It has been 7 years since we have left and 6 yrs. since the death, please ask him to make contact…………..His 1/2 brothers email is I totally understand if Jesse refuses because it is me he could be angry at, which I don’t know why? The break up was clean and non-violent. Of coarse hearts where broken but if he would give me a chance to explain, which his sister has tried, we could possibly be on talking terms agian. He never did gave me a chance so I am assuming that he will continue to disown his 1/2 brother & I, but at least I can tell his 1/2 brother I & you tried. Please respond back to me by e-mail if you choose to decline this wierd mission – I totally get it. Thanks again Mr. Glanzer and Congratulations, Good Luck, Best of Wishes to you and the new Bride.

Leave a Reply to TJ Weaver Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.